Is a paid recovery app worth it for a formatted hard drive?

I tried a free recovery app in read-only mode after I accidentally quick-formatted my external hard drive. The scan listed PDFs, but the filenames were gone. I’m preparing a job application for a technical writing role, and the sample I want to submit is a troubleshooting guide I laid out myself. The draft and the finished copy look the same until the section with the diagrams.

For a formatted hard drive, do you actually use a free recovery app or pay for one, and why? I’m particularly interested in whether you could preview an interior page before deciding what to recover.

Don’t save any recovered PDFs back to the formatted drive. If the free app lets you save the likely matches to a different drive, I’d do that and go straight to the diagrams in your usual PDF reader. Before paying for hard drive recovery software like Disk Drill, I’d open the preview and see if I could scroll to that section. I’d only pay if I could see the finished layout and the free option wouldn’t let me save it. A cover thumbnail can’t tell those drafts apart.

5 Likes

Alternatively you may want to pay for this feature. Using the Disk Drill tool you can determine if there are any recoverable files in the original folder. If the project folder appears in the results and contains identifiable draft titles, paying for this feature could be worthwhile. However, if the results contain the same anonymous files, the free version will suffice.

Check the email to see if you sent it to anyone. If so, you have more information in this version (date, recipient, and which draft) than in a scanned file. Search for the reviewer’s name in the list. If you shared a link, check the shared folder and ‘version history’.

This note gives more credibility as evidence than a file simply named ‘final.’. You can be certain that this change was made by checking the attached file. Even if it shows an earlier draft, it can be used as a reference to compare to the anonymous PDFs.

Take a few minutes to do this. If the formatted device contains the only version of your completed document then you may want to pay to recover it using recovery software. However, if the correct PDF is in an email, then recovering the project folder can be put on hold until after you have submitted your application.

If the sample was written on a different machine and the PDF was exported to the stick, do not plug it in. It does not matter here; a PDF generated from the completed source file on the app will do just as well.

Look within the app for any recently opened projects. If the recently opened file shows as being on the USB stick, then you won’t be able to find a version to edit in the places shown. However, if there is an editable version of this document on your laptop, this could save a lot of hassle. If you cannot find a project by this name, have a search in all your documents for a unique heading from the sample.

Once located, export the source onto your computer. Open the newly generated PDF and make sure that it looks okay. If diagrams are included, make sure that these have been included in the exporting. If the diagrams were linked rather than embedded, text may show up correctly but missing diagrams.

Do not pay to get the previous filenames back. However, if the final document is only available on this drive and there is a specific aspect of the document (such as a missing diagram) that can be recovered on the paid app, and not the free app, you might consider paying.

As it is a fast format, it is highly likely that the files themselves are intact. However, the file index has been lost, so the names of the files are blank. The data itself will be intact, until it is overwritten. As you have not used the external hard drive, it is unlikely that the data has been overwritten. Overall, the likelihood of recovery is good.

Important Note

It is important to note that losing a file name and corrupting a file are different things. Though there are no file names in the free version, the PDFs can be recovered via signature recognition. This works well if the file is stored in one block on the disk. However, if the file was broken up (fragmented) during saving, a partial or corrupted file may be recovered. This means that whilst opening it, half a page may be displayed. Both Disk Drill and the free scanning tools can do this. A paid version will not improve recovery of fragmented files, it simply means that you are able to save those files which were found.

Deciding whether to Pay

If the document (including charts) can be viewed in full within the preview window in the free version, then the file can definitively be recovered. All that is being paid for is the ability to click save. Depending on the importance of the file, this could be very worthwhile. However, if it cannot be previewed correctly, or a garbled page is displayed, paying will not help in recovering that particular PDF. The same file is being scanned, so a partial file will still result.

I’d slightly push back on the idea that the email route is a sidetrack. @gina had the strongest practical point in here. A sent attachment is a clean, complete copy with a timestamp, and chasing it costs you nothing and risks nothing. Recovery carving is always a gamble on fragmentation. An email attachment isn’t.

Only pay after exhausting the following: Email, Cloud backup, exporting laptop. If one of these contains the final version of your layout, just submit the application. Don’t worry about the drive. However, if you have to pay out of your own pocket, only do so if the drive is the only copy left, and the free preview shows that the file has been restored intact.

If there are only a few files open in PDF format, you can quickly scan through these. However, if there are many similar files in the folder, you can search for text within the files. If it is possible to download these candidate files to your computer using the free version of this tool, you may wish to avoid paying to rescan files.

Search for a phrase that you know was changed at the end of the project. It is best to search for changes made in captions of figures. Searching for the title of the document may return too many files. Searching for the caption will reduce this list to only contain the correct files.

This will give you a shortlist to choose from. Even if text in diagrams cannot be searched for, there may still be useful files in your shortlist. If you have found probable copies, make sure that the caption appears below the correct diagram. This gives more useful information for a writing sample, than knowing what the original filename was.

Once you have created a bit-by-bit backup / clone of your external storage device, you should continue to work from this rather than from the original physical storage. Any data reads from a potentially faulty storage disk may pose some risks. If the storage device begins to fail, it is much better to have obtained one complete image rather than an incomplete recovery from failing hardware. It is easy to create the bit-by-bit image with Disk Drill. Once cloned, it can be mounted within the same recovery application and there will be no loss of data.

On the actual pay question, I’m with the crowd that says check your sent mail and any shared link before spending a cent. @gina nailed the reason: an attachment carries a date and a recipient, which is worth more to you here than a filename ever was. A clean copy sitting in your outbox ends this whole thread.

However, do be careful with this. If there is a bad preview, this doesn’t necessarily mean the files are lost. In a largely empty external drive containing just a few PDFs, fragmentation is unlikely. Therefore try running the carving process twice on the image before assuming the files are lost. Only go for the paid version of the software if this drive really is your final copy, but you can see that the diagrams have been found in the correct place in the preview.

The same tool with the same settings will process it the same way so it will generate the same PDFs. However, if certain pages of content are missing from what the candidate has, you could try a different tool on that same image, and you can find that certain pages show up in that tool. This can be a good reason to pay.